Near Conference Road, Wilmington-Dayton Road makes two 90-degree jogs. They sit at the northeast corner of a large piece of farmland close to Sugarcreek Reserve. The Greene County Thoroughfare Plan has long recommended removing those jogs by running the road straight through that property, though no road improvements were planned as of 2020.
On Tuesday, December 8, 2026, at 7 p.m., the Sugarcreek Township Zoning Commission will take up a plan for that land again. Oberer Land Developers, LTD wants to rezone 42.740 acres at 2745 Wilmington Dayton Road from E (Rural Estate Residential) to PUD-R (Residential Planned Unit Development). The company is also seeking preliminary approval for a 43-lot subdivision. The two parcels involved total 80.712 acres. The hearing is at the township administration office, 2090 Ferry Road, according to the township's notice. The commission first heard the case on November 10 and tabled it to the December date.
If you're house hunting in Bellbrook, this hearing affects you. It is the largest new-home proposal on the township's calendar, and the developer's interest in this land goes back to 2017. Read next to the area's sales numbers, that history shows how small a share of Bellbrook's yearly market even a full new subdivision would be.
The same land drew 98 homes in 2018 and draws 43 now
This isn't Oberer's first plan for this property. In August 2017 the developer agreed to buy part of the land for Elliot Woods, a patio-home neighborhood first drawn at 113 lots. After road work at three intersections, including removing the two jogs in Wilmington-Dayton Road, was added to the plan, about 15 lots came out. In July 2018 Oberer filed a revised plan with 98 lots, with half the land kept as open space at 1.2 homes per acre. For comparison, nearby Woodland Ridge sits at 1.5 homes per acre and Black Farm at 2.95.
About 130 people came to the Zoning Commission meeting on December 4, 2018. Many spoke against the plan over road and traffic concerns and over density, and the commission voted 5-0 to recommend denial. On March 18, 2019, the trustees denied the application, citing traffic and safety, the intersections, how densely the patio homes were clustered, and strong local opposition.
The 2026 application is a different plan. It asks to rezone 42.740 acres, not about 84, and proposes 43 lots, not 98. The township's notices don't list lot sizes or home styles. The full application can be viewed at the Ferry Road office from 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. on weekdays, or by appointment at 937-848-8426.
Forty-three lots, set against about 224 sales a year
Dayton REALTORS® reports yearly sales for the combined Bellbrook/Sugarcreek area, which is the only Bellbrook-level view it publishes. Here is what those yearly reports show:
| Year | Homes sold, Bellbrook/Sugarcreek | Median sale price |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 280 | not used here |
| 2022 | 242 | $395,000 |
| 2023 | 250 | $414,500 |
| 2025 | 224 | $382,301 |
Sales went from 280 in 2021 to 242 in 2022, ticked up to 250 in 2023, and came in at 224 in 2025, 20% below the 2021 count. Across a city and a whole township, 224 sales in 2025 comes to fewer than 20 a month. If all 43 proposed lots were built and sold, they would add up to less than a fifth of one year's sales at the 2025 pace.
For a buyer, that ratio is the main point. Even the largest new-home proposal on the township's calendar is small next to the homes that change hands here every year, so the Bellbrook search that matters for most buyers is the one among homes already standing.
Why the Bellbrook median dropped while the region rose
In 2025 the Bellbrook/Sugarcreek median sale price was $382,301, and the average was $455,612. When the average sits that far above the median, a group of high-priced sales is pulling it up, while the typical home sold for much less.
The median also moved in a direction that may surprise some buyers. It was $414,500 in 2023 and $382,301 in 2025. Over a similar stretch, the Dayton REALTORS® regional median kept rising. For January through October 2026 it was $264,900, up 3.88% from $255,000 for the same months of 2025.
In a market this small, the median depends on which houses happen to sell in a given year. With about 224 sales, a few dozen more smaller homes or a few dozen fewer large ones can move the midpoint by tens of thousands of dollars, even if no single home lost value. A lower Bellbrook median doesn't mean Bellbrook homes got cheaper. It means a different mix of homes reached the market in 2025. When I price a home here, I compare it with sales on the same kind of street and lot, because the area-wide median tells you more about what sold than about what any one house is worth.
Bellbrook next to Beavercreek, Centerville and Springboro
The same 2025 Dayton REALTORS® report shows how much thinner Bellbrook's market is than its neighbors':
- Beavercreek and Beavercreek Township: 806 homes sold, median $345,000
- Centerville and Washington Township: 954 homes sold, median $337,950
- Springboro and Clearcreek Township: 572 homes sold, median $475,000
- Bellbrook and Sugarcreek: 224 homes sold, median $382,301
Beavercreek sold about 67 homes a month in 2025. Bellbrook/Sugarcreek sold about 19. Centerville and Washington Township sold about 80. If you're open to more than one of these suburbs, that gap changes how you search, because a Bellbrook search draws on roughly a quarter of the sales that either of those suburbs sees.
The region overall has a little more room right now. Dayton REALTORS® counted 3,072 active listings across the Miami Valley in October 2026, or 2.5 months of supply, and homes sold for 99.1% of list price on average that month. The regional median for October was $250,000. Those figures cover the whole region, so they tell you about financing and buyer demand in general. They say little about how many Bellbrook homes will come up between now and spring.
I've written a side-by-side look at Beavercreek and Bellbrook for families weighing the two. The sales counts above are the practical side of that choice, since a smaller market gives a buyer fewer homes to choose from in any given month.
How to plan a Bellbrook search around a small market
If Bellbrook or the Bellbrook side of Sugarcreek Township is your first choice, plan your search around a small number of sales.
Get your financing approved before a listing appears. With fewer than 20 sales a month, the right house may not come along often, and you'll want to be ready when it does. Our buyer resources and mortgage calculator are a starting point for that groundwork.
Set price expectations from homes like the one you want, not from the area median. Because of the gap between the $382,301 median and the $455,612 average, a buyer looking for a newer two-story and a buyer looking for an older ranch are effectively shopping in different markets that share one ZIP code.
Don't build your timeline around new construction. The 43-lot plan on Wilmington-Dayton Road is a proposal with a hearing on December 8, and at full size it would still be a fraction of one year's Bellbrook sales.
If you already own in Bellbrook and are thinking about moving up or downsizing, the same numbers work in your favor. With fewer than 20 sales a month, a well-prepared listing has less company. A home valuation built on recent sales like yours is a better guide than any area-wide figure.
If you're weighing Bellbrook against Beavercreek or Centerville and want to know what fewer than 20 sales a month means for your timeline, Donte Scott is glad to talk it through with you. Schedule a free, no-pressure consultation, and we'll set up a search plan around how Bellbrook homes actually come up for sale.